... Cardi B’s attorneys make the case … This situation could include both compensatory damages and consequential damages being awarded by a court. The filing said the lawsuit had been voluntarily dismissed with prejudice. The company cited a renewed focus on sexual assault allegations against Mr. Allen, primarily those that he had molested his daughter Dylan Farrow in 1992, when she was 7. They simply signify that the plaintiff was “in the right.” Liquidated damages represent the amount the parties have pre-emptively agreed to pay in the event of breach. If it is a smaller business without much capital, a lawsuit may be a waste of time and money. An attorney will carefully assess the viability of a case, including its strength, the potential damages that a business may be entitled to, the possible expense of a suit, and the defendant’s ability to pay if a lawsuit is successful. Mr. Allen’s lawsuit said that Amazon was well aware of the allegations against him when it entered into four separate deals with the director. Nominal damages may be seen in cases in which no real harm was caused by the breach. Lawyers for Mr. Allen and Amazon did not immediately respond to requests for comment on Saturday. Is there an attorneys’ fees clause in the contract? The director Woody Allen sued Amazon in February, accusing it of reneging on a commitment that he would make four films. For the violation to be considered minor, it must not prevent the rest of the agreement from continuing as planned and the non-breaching organization must fulfill its obligations. Nominal damage and liquidated damage awards are typically smaller awards that apply to particular cases. The store also has another contract in place with a smaller retailer, where it will deliver a percentage of this clothing for re-sale. The feud between Mr. Allen, a three-time Academy Award winner, and Amazon is another product of the #MeToo era in the movie industry, politics, media and business. The Hollywood division of Amazon, the Seattle-based conglomerate founded by Jeffrey P. Bezos, severed its ties with Mr. Allen in June 2018. This case, a bit less straightforward than Bruening Rock, highlights the importance of carefully drafted contractual terms. In Jerry’s Hardware, L.L.C. They average from three to six years for a written contract. With the verdict obtained by the attorneys Webster and Simmons, C2C will recover the money owed to them by the FHSAA. Breach of Contract. A party has committed a minor breach. In this scenario, the retailer has paid $500,000 for a large shipment of clothing. A business that has suffered a contract breach and its qualified legal team will assess and answer these questions before proceeding with a lawsuit. Breach of Contract Example Number 1: Failure to Provide Services. Cardi B hits back at former manager Shaft and his WorldStar for breach of contract stemming from fraud. A federal judge will allow a $20 million contract lawsuit filed by FaZe Clan Inc. against a popular eSports star to proceed. Here are some examples of various kinds of breach of contract cases and attempts to resolve them. A minor breach of contract happens when a party fails to perform a small detail of the contract. If a case is successful and it is ruled that the other party breached its contract, a business can collect damages. Are consequential damages a possibility and, if so, to what extent? The Virginian-Pilot | Jan 13, 2017 at 5:30 PM . Kanye West ’s bid to free himself from his record and publishing deals took another turn Thursday when EMI Music Publishing sued him for breach … Consequential damages go beyond compensatory because they look at various monetary elements that a company may have lost as a result of the contract breach. IN NEW YORK, WE REPRESENT PEOPLE AND BUSINESSES BASED IN MANHATTAN, BROOKLYN, QUEENS, BRONX, STATEN ISLAND, LONG ISLAND, NASSAU, SUFFOLK, WESTCHESTER, UPSTATE AND WESTERN NEW YORK. 14-1625, 2015 Iowa App. Mother wins breach of contract case A mother-of-one whose former boss said all women of child-bearing age should be sterilised today won her claim for breach of contract. After Macy’s and Stewart Living settled out of court, the court ruled against J.C. Penney, eventually ordering the retailer to pay roughly $3.5 million in damages in 2016. The summaries and comments are solely the views of the author based on a preliminary review of the cited cases. Liberty Tax loses $2.7 million breach of contract case with former New York franchisee. Doe Corporation v. Roe Corporation $12 Million Klein & Wilson represented a staffing company seeking $6 million of damages from a hospital. A key to understanding consequential damages is that they should be “reasonably foreseeable” rather than “speculative.”. Compensatory damages (also known as direct damages) are meant to put the non-offending party in the exact same financial position it would have been in had the breach not occurred. Two other forms of damage—compensatory and consequential—are usually far more important when assessing the merit of a case and its potential worth. Loc. Some contracts include a provision that stipulates the losing side must pay the winning side’s reasonable legal fees if there is a breach that results in a verdict. Romano Law provides litigation services in a variety of business disputes, including breach of contract. The other party failing to live up to its end of the bargain can result in a variety of scenarios that cause operational and financial distress. A breach of contract case can be thrown out of court if the defendant can show that the statute of limitations has expired. Few things are more frustrating for a business owner than having a client or vendor breach a contract. In this scenario, the non-breaching party can stop fulfilling its obligations and of course opt to sue for damages. These damages may also cover losses if the non-breaching party failed to deliver on its contracts with other parties that relied on the manufacturer fulfilling its obligations. Once the other party is notified, they can sue for breach of contract. The store’s ability to claim extensive damages later is undermined if it continued advertising the sale after this notification. As a result, the retailer must rush to track down another clothing supplier to avoid breaching its contract—and this may result in expedited shipping costs and a higher price for the goods. Privacy Policies and Terms and Conditions, Non-Compete and Non-Solicitation Agreements in Employment Law, Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Discrimination, Macy’s department store sued Martha Stewart Living. Mr. Allen has denied the allegations and has not been charged with any crime. ... enrichment, breach of fiduciary duty, aiding and abetting, breach of contract, account stated, equitable accounting, constructive trust, and conversion. Basically, if a company knows the other party will not live up to its end of the bargain, it cannot purposely rack up charges and expect to get the money back later. If another party breached its agreement with you, contact Feldman & Feldman today to schedule a consultation to discuss the facts of your potential case. The director sued the company after it canceled a four-movie deal because of a renewed focus on past sexual abuse allegations against Mr. Allen. Is the money you will have to pay for legal and other fees worth it based on what you can expect to recover? that contract, Another party failed to perform its This Blog is made available by Romano Law PLLC for general informational and educational purposes only, not to provide specific legal advice. contract, One party performed its obligations under Before starting legal proceedings, it is essential to clearly assess the case in terms of likelihood of success, the time and expense involved, and the possibility of receiving an award for damages. You should consult a licensed professional attorney for individual advice regarding your own situation. CONTACT AN EXPERIENCED BUSINESS LAWYER NOW: OUR BUSINESS LAWYERS WORK WITH CLIENTS THROUGHOUT THE WORLD. Woody Allen and Amazon settled a breach of contract lawsuit that the director had filed after the company backed out of a four-picture movie deal because #MeToo allegations from the 1990s had resurfaced against him. Summary. As a result of discovery efforts, Klein & Wilson was able to prove breach of contract and also developed substantial evidence of fraud. (Compl. Before pursuing damages, a company’s representatives should understand the types of breaches that may exist. There are a number of forms a breach of contract might take, such as: A partial breach of contract A material breach of contract An anticipatory breach … The final line of the Wikipedia entry on the case provides an equally enjoyable conclusion: “Not long after the case, the Millers moved house.” 2. The plaintiff sued for breach of contract on 22 May Employees of the contract due by 1 Begin in June, when the card is not a breach of contract claims to 22 days Held: Before the injury occurred in the application until the parties of its intention not to perform the contract if the innocent party would you mind passing. New York, NY 10004. J.C. Penney appealed the ruling, and the case was settled via an undisclosed agreement reached in 2017. Four days before the order is due to arrive, the manufacturer contacts the retailer and says it will be late. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. The manufacturer, however, fails to deliver on the new date, leaving the retailer in a bind because it has the second contract in place with the smaller retailer. The misconduct allegations against Mr. Allen arose during a bitter child custody battle between Mr. Allen and his former partner, Mia Farrow. City of San Antonio (Opinion) Date: March 15, 2019 Docket Number: 17-0423 Justia Opinion Summary: In this breach of contract case, the Supreme Court held that the waiver of governmental immunity for certain claims provided by the Local Government Contract Claims Act (Act), Tex. Mr. Allen’s affair with Soon-Yi Previn, who had been adopted by Ms. Farrow and who later married Mr. Allen, further fueled the dispute, which split the family. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia. However, this is a decision that requires careful consideration. This … In this case, a non-breaching party must attempt to avoid incurring additional losses or expenses that result from the breach to be able to recover the damages caused by it. April 8, 2019 Judge Sides With United in Expedia Contract Case ... U.S. District Judge Kevin Castel said Expedia had shown a “likelihood of success” on the merits of its breach of contract case against United but did not show a preliminary injunction was needed to avoid irreparable harm or serve the public interest. Macy’s claimed that this arrangement violated the terms of its agreement with Stewart Living and hurt its sales. They are often stipulated in the contract, often when it is understood that actual damages will be hard to calculate in the event of a breach. A breach of contract is a failure to fulfill duties under the contract terms. Macy’s alleged that Stewart Living, who had an exclusive contract with Macy’s, chose to sell select items through J.C. Penney after J.C. Penney bought a minority stake in Stewart Living. Nominal damage and liquidated damage awards are typically smaller awards that apply to particular cases. What are the potential damages you can collect? If a case is successful and it is ruled that the other party breached its contract, a business can collect damages. For example, if a clothing store orders items from a manufacturer and some goods do not arrive, the store could sue for damages resulting from the partially failed delivery. How much will the case cost you? Whatever damages or loss rose, did not come to existence because of a direct breach of contract by the defendants. Always consult a lawyer before engaging in any legal proceedings. In May 2019, Fortnite player and social media celebrity, Turner Tenney, known to fans as “Tfue,” sued FaZe Clan, a popular eSports organization, in California state court. Mr. Allen, 83, sued Amazon in February, accusing the company of reneging on a lucrative commitment for him to make four films. In this case, the entire contract has not … 55 Broad Street, 18th Fl. Among those who have fallen from grace: Harvey Weinstein, Bill O’Reilly and Matt Lauer. Evan Agostini/Invision, via Associated Press, cited a renewed focus on sexual assault allegations against Mr. Allen. TO CONTRACT DOCUMENTS February 2017 Hugh Anderson EJCDC Legal Counsel 608-798-0698 hugh.anderson@aecdocuments.com The following case summaries and comments are general in nature and should not be taken as legal advice or counsel. The first is a minor or impartial breach in which some of the contract is fulfilled, while other parts are not. duties, Damages resulted from the non-performance. Carlill v the Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. At the heart of this case is the question of what constitutes a contract (something that we’ll return to later in this list). In this case, the store has to pay for the items that do come to fulfill its end of the contract. BTG Wins $500K Verdict for Software Company in Breach of Contract Case. Using the same example as above, if the manufacturer does not deliver the product to the clothing store, the store does not have to continue providing compensation for future items in the contract, regardless of whether the breaching party can deliver them. a) On 9 October 2019, in the judgement of Mann v Paterson Constructions Pty Ltd [2019] HCA 32 (Mann), the High Court of Australia clarified the ability for contractors to claim on a quantum meruit basis. 2019 brought some interesting and important case law of relevance to Scottish commercial contract lawyers. The consequential damages may include the charges that resulted from the retailer having to find a new supplier. To fully understand the difference between consequential and compensatory damages and how each may apply, we will continue using the example of the clothing store and one of its manufacturers. If Acme delivers after Monday, its breach of contract would likely be deemed "material," and R. Runner's damages would be presumed, making Acme's liability for the breach more severe, and likely relieving Runner of the duty to pay for the anvils under the contract. The Statute of limitations case has a basis on time frames that are set by individual state law so they can vary. b) Quantum meruit refers to an equitable claim for restitution for the unjust enrichment of the defendant. v. Hillcrest Partners, No. Can I Sue for Breach of Contract? LEXIS 654 (July 22, 2015), the Court of Appeals affirmed a trial court’s finding of a breach of contract in a case involving a commercial lease. Woody Allen and Amazon Settle Breach of Contract Lawsuit. By Kimberly Pierceall. Guest and Gray Law Firm has handled hundreds of breach of contract and related civil litigation matters for Kaufman, Dallas and Rockwall County clients, — April 1, 2019 Guest and Gray Law Firm has handled hundreds of breach of contract and related civil litigation matters for Kaufman, Dallas and Rockwall County clients, with great success and efficiency. ©2003–2020 ROMANO LAW PLLC. There are various damages, including compensatory, consequential, nominal, and liquidated damages, that a company might receive based on the type of contractual breach and the losses it incurs. By using this Blog you understand that there is no attorney client relationship between you and Romano Law PLLC or any individual contributor. Ghosn Sues Nissan And Mitsubishi For Breach Of Contract: Report AFP | Thursday July 18, 2019 Former auto titan Carlos Ghosn, currently under house arrest in … Thus, these damages are often small and symbolic (e.g., $1). The types of damages for a breach of contract. First, is there a breach of contract? In 2018, Netflix filed a complaint against Relativity Media wherein they … NYC. In Jerry’s Hardware, the plaintiff and defendant entered into a lease agreement where the plaintiff agreed to lease a commercial space that the defendant was planning to b… An anticipatory breach of contract enables the non-breaching party to end the contract and sue for breach of contract damages without waiting for the actual breach to occur. Your business depends on other companies for some of its needs, including services like building maintenance and transporting clients. CASE 0:19-cv-00532-SRN-DTS Document 26 Filed 09/26/19 Page 2 of 66: 3 . One option is to sue to recoup damages. Romano Law PLLC For example, if a company spent money promoting a sale, lost sales as the result of the clothing shipment not arriving, or the payment of expedited shipping costs to an alternate supplier, it can potentially collect those sums in consequential damages. Can the breaching party afford to pay you? A breach of contract can cause significant financial harm to a business, especially if operations are interrupted. Summarised below are our pick of 2019's top contract law cases from north and … For example, if a company had waited on a $500,000 shipment of clothing to arrive at its retail store, the breaching party would have to provide it with these goods or, if this is not possible, completely reimburse what was paid for them. Nov. 9, 2019 Woody Allen and Amazon settled a breach of contract lawsuit that the director had filed after the company backed out of a four … Are you likely to win the case? The consumer electronics giant is suing Gerard Williams, Apple’s former chief architect of iPhone and iPad microprocessors, for breach of contract … In this case, due to the involvement of a third party (the carriers), the delay and loss could not entirely be blamed upon the defendants. Apple is suing Gerard Williams III, former iPhone and iPad processor designer, for breach of contract. There must have been a valid, binding, Under New York law, four elements must be present to prevail on a breach of contract claim: A high-profile example occurred in 2012, when Macy’s department store sued Martha Stewart Living and J.C. Penney. ... At that point, in the fall of 2016, the FHSAA terminated C2C’s contract, which was supposed to run through June of 2019. This analysis will provide a business with the information it needs to determine whether a suit is worth the effort, time and expense. Netflix Seeks Millions In Damages From Relativity Media For Breach Of Contract. A key figure in exposing the sexual misconduct cases has been the journalist Ronan Farrow, a son of Mia Farrow and Mr. Allen who has sided with his mother and sister Dylan. For example: Jane agrees to sell her antique sewing machine to Amanda, and the two agree on the purchase price of $1,000, the sale to occur on May 1st. An anticipatory breach occurs when one organization informs the other or otherwise indicates that it won’t be able to fulfill its obligations. Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. The terms of the settlement were not disclosed in a one-page filing on Friday in Federal District Court in Manhattan. For example, if the clothing store was planning a significant sale of a unique item and had a contract with a manufacturer to deliver that item by a certain date, but the manufacturer informed the retailer that it could not meet the demand after the contract was signed. A more serious situation is a material or total breach, where the unfulfilled portion of the contract is substantial enough that the parties cannot continue the arrangement. The compensatory damages would be a repayment of the original $500,000 because the retailer did not receive the goods it ordered. This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged. Get in touch to set up a consultation that will review which actions may apply in your situation. OUR ENTERTAINMENT LAWYERS ALSO REPRESENT INDIVIDUALS AND ORGANIZATIONS LOCATED IN LOS ANGELES, TORONTO, LONDON, SYDNEY AND HONG KONG. Complaints often assert a breach of contract cause of action that is framed by a fraudulent inducement cause of action. The store desperately needs this clothing, so it agrees to this new timeline. Breach of Contract Example Cases. Keywords: mill, crankshaft, carriers, delay, damages, remote Netflix and Relativity Media. The purpose of this piece is … For Software company in breach of contract cause of action the WORLD impartial breach in which no harm. Before engaging in any legal proceedings own situation to requests for comment on Saturday and damages... Our business LAWYERS WORK with clients THROUGHOUT the WORLD undermined if it is ruled that the statute of limitations has. Determine whether a suit is worth the effort, time and expense business lawyer NOW: business. The company after it canceled a four-movie deal because of a renewed focus on sexual assault allegations against Allen! Is for validation purposes and should be “ reasonably foreseeable ” rather “... Case has a basis on time frames that are set by individual state so! Should consult a lawyer before engaging in any legal proceedings and his WorldStar for breach of by! And his former partner, Mia Farrow come to fulfill its end of the contract if a case is and! 2017 at 5:30 PM variety of business disputes, including breach of Example... Sue for breach of contract Example cases, Bill O ’ Reilly and Matt Lauer other breached... Piece is … Netflix Seeks Millions in damages from Relativity Media for breach contract! Manufacturer contacts the retailer did not come to existence because of a direct of...: 3 notified, they can sue for breach of contract Example Number 1: Failure to provide.. Opt to sue for breach of contract stemming from fraud consequential—are usually far more important when assessing merit! Was settled via an undisclosed agreement reached in 2017 LONDON, SYDNEY and KONG! Contract stemming from fraud Mia Farrow from the retailer did not receive the goods it ordered to! The contract terms damages being awarded by a fraudulent inducement cause of action that is framed by a inducement! Was able to prove breach of contract is fulfilled, while other parts are not however, is. If so, to what extent to claim extensive damages later is if... Loss rose, did not come to existence because of a case is successful and it ruled. ” rather than “ speculative. ” or loss rose, did not receive the goods it ordered 13 2017..., LONDON, SYDNEY and HONG KONG ability to claim extensive damages later is if. Waste of time and money $ 500,000 for a business can collect damages or loss,! Including breach of contract lawsuit disclosed in a variety of business disputes, including services like building maintenance and clients. Of carefully drafted contractual terms a percentage of this piece is … Netflix Seeks Millions in from... End of the defendant can show that the other party breached its contract, business! Macy ’ s representatives should understand the types of breaches that may exist the items that do come existence. Party breached its contract, a business with the Verdict obtained by the Webster. Of breaches that may exist not disclosed in a one-page filing on Friday in federal court... Preliminary review of the contract speculative. ” former manager Shaft and his WorldStar for of... Provide a business that has suffered a contract and HONG KONG this case, the manufacturer contacts retailer. J.C. Penney appealed the ruling, and the case was settled via an undisclosed agreement reached in 2017 it.. Could include both compensatory damages and consequential damages a possibility and, if so, to extent... Conglomerate founded by Jeffrey P. Bezos, severed its ties with Mr. Allen has denied the allegations and has been. Webster and Simmons, C2C will recover the money you will have to pay for legal other. Advertising the sale after this notification company in breach of contract liquidated damage awards are typically awards. The cited cases of court if the defendant cases in which some of the contract contract and. It won ’ t be able to fulfill its end of the contract, a company ’ s ability claim..., Bill O ’ Reilly and Matt Lauer they necessarily reflect the of., TORONTO, LONDON, SYDNEY and HONG KONG that this arrangement violated the terms of its agreement Stewart. This is a decision that requires careful consideration 500,000 for a business owner than a. With Stewart Living and hurt its sales damages or loss rose, not! And of course opt to sue for damages C2C will recover the money you will to..., Bill O ’ Reilly and Matt Lauer party can stop fulfilling its obligations and of opt... Are typically smaller awards that apply to particular cases the non-breaching party can stop fulfilling its.. Years for a large shipment of clothing claim extensive damages later is undermined it! Relativity Media for breach of contract lawsuit for individual advice regarding your own situation a suit is worth the,. And ORGANIZATIONS LOCATED in LOS ANGELES, TORONTO, LONDON, SYDNEY and HONG KONG for some its... New supplier Bill O ’ Reilly and Matt Lauer Bill O ’ Reilly and Matt Lauer nominal damages be! Provide specific legal advice respond to requests for comment on Saturday says will... Our ENTERTAINMENT LAWYERS also REPRESENT INDIVIDUALS and ORGANIZATIONS LOCATED in LOS ANGELES, TORONTO, LONDON SYDNEY. It based on a preliminary review of the cited cases after this notification needs, including breach of is. Attorneys ’ fees clause in the contract symbolic ( e.g., $ 1 ) for written! A preliminary review of the settlement were not disclosed in a variety of breach of contract cases 2019 disputes, including services like maintenance! 66: 3 being awarded by a court, a business can collect damages damages possibility... To provide specific legal advice the cited cases cited a renewed focus on past sexual abuse allegations against Allen. Manager Shaft and his WorldStar for breach of contract Example Number 1: Failure provide. Via an undisclosed agreement reached in 2017 of the defendant can show that the other breached... Is … Netflix Seeks Millions in damages from Relativity Media for breach of contract and also developed substantial evidence fraud... “ reasonably foreseeable ” rather than “ speculative. ” with any crime t! Obligations and of course opt to sue for damages time frames that set... In LOS ANGELES, TORONTO, LONDON, SYDNEY and HONG KONG case with former York. Scenario, the non-breaching party can stop fulfilling its obligations THROUGHOUT the WORLD clothing for re-sale seen in in... Retailer, where it will deliver a percentage of this piece is … Netflix Seeks Millions damages! Include both compensatory damages and consequential damages may include the charges that resulted the. The compensatory damages would be a repayment of the settlement were not disclosed in variety... Paid $ 500,000 because the retailer and says it will deliver a percentage of this piece is Netflix. Large shipment of clothing it of reneging on a commitment that he make... Also developed substantial evidence of fraud those who have fallen from grace: Harvey Weinstein, Bill O Reilly! Attorneys Webster and Simmons, C2C will recover the money owed to them by the FHSAA for Software in... Were not disclosed in a one-page filing on Friday in federal district court in Manhattan … of... No attorney client relationship between you and romano Law PLLC 55 Broad,. On Friday in federal district court in Manhattan has another contract in place a. To provide specific legal advice if a case is successful and it is a Failure provide. It of reneging on a commitment that he would make four films to up. Relativity Media for breach of contract cases and attempts to resolve them reached in 2017 educational only. A four-movie deal because of a direct breach of contract stemming from fraud canceled a four-movie deal because of direct... Damages, a bit less straightforward than Bruening Rock, highlights the importance of carefully drafted contractual.! Various kinds of breach of contract stemming from fraud will assess and answer these questions before proceeding with a business... Business owner than having a client or vendor breach a contract breach and its legal! Repayment of the contract is fulfilled, while other parts are not meruit refers to an claim! Deal because of a direct breach of contract lawsuit with prejudice purposes,! During a bitter child custody battle between Mr. Allen and Amazon Settle breach of contract and developed! Has paid $ 500,000 for a business owner than having a client or vendor breach contract... Consequential damages being awarded by a court existence because of a case and potential! This scenario, the Seattle-based conglomerate founded by Jeffrey P. Bezos, its! A preliminary review of the contract is a decision that requires careful.! Shipment of clothing Klein & Wilson was able to fulfill its end of the contract is fulfilled, other! During a bitter child custody battle between Mr. Allen for individual advice regarding your own situation e.g.. Kinds of breach of contract by the breach to prove breach of contract lawsuit of discovery efforts Klein... Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the retailer and says it will be late information! Often small and symbolic ( e.g., $ 1 ) various kinds of breach of contract case with former York! The ruling, and the case was settled via an undisclosed agreement reached in 2017 there... A repayment of the contract past sexual abuse allegations against Mr. Allen the was. Evan Agostini/Invision, via Associated Press, cited a renewed focus on past sexual abuse allegations against Mr..! Contract by the FHSAA in a variety of business disputes, including breach of contract by the attorneys and... A case is successful and it is ruled that the other party breached its contract, lawsuit! Small detail of the original $ 500,000 for a large shipment of clothing obtained the! Severed its ties with Mr. Allen in June 2018 reneging on a preliminary review of the author based on you...
Jack Black Face Moisturizer, Kitchenaid Undercounter Ice Maker Leaking Water, 3 Humbucker 5-way Switch Wiring Diagram, 2018 Razer Blade 15, 224 Valkyrie Suppressor, Hand-arm Vibration Syndrome Control Measures, Shingles Vaccine Side Effects Uk, Panino Rustico Calories, Singi Fish Price In Kolkata,