Therefore, a discretionary fiscal policy will stabilize the economy most when surpluses are incurred during inflation and deficits during recessions. Get Your Custom Essay Given the uncertainties over interest rate effects, time lags, temporary and permanent policies, and unpredictable political behavior, many economists and knowledgeable policymakers had concluded by the mid-1990s that discretionary fiscal policy was a blunt instrument, more like a club than a scalpel. At recession, the state of GDP in terms of aggregate supply and also aggregate demand are usually not at equilibrium. It is because of these lags that Friedman argues that discretionary public policy will often be destabilizing. can use them for free to gain inspiration and new creative ideas for their writing assignments. For this reason, he argued the case for general rules rather than discretionary policy. gov/ftpdocs/89xx/doc8916/MainText. lag in discretionary policy. Generally, time lags may cause preferential economic instability where such tools used to overcome their effects become negatively implicating. Implementation lag is the length of period between decision of the economic policy makers on the actual response to the fundamental change in the economy and implementation of this response to the legislation. Upon implementation of the discretionary policy, these prior investments could be affected by massive competition of new investment resulting in a scenario where the discretionary fiscal will worsen the economic condition. Discretionary fiscal policy involves the same kind of lags as monetary policy. There is usually a time lag between when a change in policy is needed and when its need is widely recognized by policymakers. ADVERTISEMENT. 1. Don’t miss a chance to chat with experts. Time lags in Discretionary Fiscal Policy, besides consuming some considerable amount of time, are also very unpredictable. The result was that the people believed that the added policy was short and late. The use of discretionary fiscal policy is hampered by three time lags: Recognition lag. The federal government’s headquarters is centered in. "Discretionary policy" can refer to decision making in both monetary policy and fiscal policy. Monetary policy and fiscal policy refer to the two most widely recognized tools used to influence a nation's economic activity. Let Professional Writer Help You, 6000 Fairview Road, SouthPark Towers, Suite 1200, Charlotte, NC 28210, USA. The lags in discretionary fiscal policy. argued that discretionary fiscal policy is not an effective stabilisation toolEspecially from a . In Alaska ;transportation bill, nearly $1 billion went to Alaska, 47th populous state just behind California and Illinois -ultimately eliminated for the bridges, but still got the funding Congress's inability. ... Fiscal policy lag effect. Expansionary fiscal policy can help to end recessions and contractionary fiscal policy can help to reduce inflation. The word 'monetary' refers to the money supply of a nation, which is controlled by the central bank. A discretionary fiscal policy. According to Auerbach (2002), “the impact of policy on current activity depends on expectations about the future”. UK Budget deficit. A government may implement a deflationary fiscal policy (also called a contractionary fiscal policy) to reduce inflationary pressure. When congress or the president proposes fiscal policies to correct unhealthy economic conditions, the time it takes from the recognition of the problem, to the proposal of a solution, to. The economic literature on policy coordination tends to be about situations where the fiscal and monetary authorities have one or more of the following: very different views of economic welfare, 5 inconsistent policy objectives, policy that is totally discretionary, or a tendency to get involved in game-like behaviour with one another. A business-cycle contraction that hits the economy on January 1st cannot be correct with fiscal policy by January 2nd. The Federal Reserve Bank uses monetary policy to control and moderate the volume of money, as well as credit and interest rates. Stanford University, Retrieved September 15, 2007 from http://www.stanford.edu/~johntayl/Papers/Reassessing+Revised.pdf, Cooper, K. (2002). There are 3 types of lags that are associated with a fiscal policy : recognition lag, decision lag and implem view the full answer. Comparing Monetary Policy to a Fiscal Policy Time Lags of Monetary and Fiscal Policies GDP: Fiscal and Monetary Policy monetary and fiscal policies macroeconomics questions for monetary policy Monetary Policy: Money, Credit, the Federal Reserve U.S. Federal monetary policy Discretionary fiscal policy Monetary Policy of India Lags. a. The Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City. History informs us about the first method the parties developed in order to pick their presidential candidates. Test. Don’t miss a chance to chat with experts. Retrieved September 15, 2007 from http://www.kansascityfed.org/publicat/Sympos/2002/pdf/S02auerbach.pdf, Remember. Are desirable, because they result in eliminating the gaps. $2.19. For example “temporary investment incentives may work in the opposite direction strengthening the immediate response but also, potentially, weakening prior investment” (Auerbach, 2002). False 40. Misappropriated time lags lead to disequilibria in the economic markets. Its purpose is to expand or shrink the economy as needed. Fiscal policy has traditionally been related to the use of taxation and public expenditure to influence economic activities of a country. The effect of time lags in discretionary fiscal policy in the economic growth and development by the congress and the president captures a broad economic phenomenon. Fiscal policy is most effective when policy lags are _____. Why time lags in discretionary fiscal policy can adversely affect the efforts of the Congress and the President in attempting to maintain a healthy economy.Could it happen that these time lags could actually work to destabilize the economy? Tight fiscal policy will tend to cause an improvement in the government budget deficit. Learn. SEMIOTICS ASSIGNMENT The front cover of TIME magazine, issued on December 10, 2007 was taken before the start of the presidential campaign in America, and the man on the front. Similarly, contractionary policy may “crowd in” additional … Therefore, a discretionary fiscal policy will stabilize the economy most when surpluses are incurred during inflation and deficits during recessions. Similarly, contractionary policy may “crowd in” additional … Monetary Policy. 2. C) Information reaction lag. Don't use plagiarized sources. on. Fiscal Policy Lags In order for there to be a reasonable chance of achieving the outcome desired from the application of particular economic policies it is important for there to be an ability to recognize the existence of a challenge, to correctly diagnose the condition, to take action in accordance with the approved policy, for all of it to be timed appropriately and to have some luck. The effect of time lags in discretionary fiscal policy in the economic growth and development by the congress and the president captures a broad economic phenomenon. So within the period of the time lag, the conditions may alter in such a way that when the discretionary policy is already in place it is no longer applicable, or it could make the situation worst where the change of conditions within the time lag would work in such a way that it makes things worst. Given the uncertainties over interest rate effects, time lags, temporary and permanent policies, and unpredictable political behavior, many economists and knowledgeable policymakers had concluded by the mid-1990s that discretionary fiscal policy was a blunt instrument, more like a club than a scalpel. Certain measures, such as varying the expenditure programs and tax rates, may have temporary stabilizing effects. That occurs after a rise in unemployment, for example, which is reported after a trend has already occurred. The federal government’s headquarters is centered in. Are undesirable, because the policy action may be inappropriate by the time its impact is felt . cbo. Unless the variations in taxes and public expenditure are neatly timed, the desired counter-cyclical effects can not be realized. History informs us about the first method the parties developed in order to pick their presidential candidates. Time Lags in Discretionary Fiscal Policy In general, it takes anywhere from six to twelve months after implementing policy changes to experience major improvements. Discretionary fiscal policy refers to government policy that alters government spending or taxes. Expansionary fiscal policy may result in the crowding out of private investment and net exports, reducing the impact of the policy. In this lesson summary review and remind yourself of the key terms, calculations, and graphs related to fiscal policy. Fiscal policy in the form of tax rates and government expenditure influence business cycles and affect greatly on the length and variability of the lag. The implementation of fiscal policy is basically rooted in the budget of the government. Takes time for democracies to pass laws. Average implementation lag of discretionary fiscal policy in the Czech Republic is 2.4 quarters. jbanton14. Flashcards. Scholars political economy point of view, long decision and implementation lags associated with discretionary fiscal policy are often mentioned as arguments why such policies might be ineffective. Time Lags in Discretionary Fiscal Policy Terms in this set (6) Discretionary fiscal policy -deliberate changes in gov spending and taxing to influence economy. At its best, discretionary fiscal policy should work in alignment with monetary policy enacted by the Federal Reserve. These time lags can be grouped into three different phases, the recognition time lag, the implementation time lag, and the response time lag. Policy Implications of Lags in Monetary Policy: The existence of long and variable lags in the effects of monetary changes has led Friedman to conclude that discretionary countercyclical policy aimed at economic stabilisation may be destabilising. Don't use plagiarized sources. This method was the congressional caucus. 39. A discretionary fiscal policy is the level of legislative parameters which are used as action policies for providing stimulus for the effect of control of economic recession. TRUE or FALSE: Because of the lags inherent to discretionary fiscal policy, such policy is as likely to be pro-cyclical as it is to be counter-cyclical. However, the implementation lag in fiscal policy is likely to be more pronounced, while the impact lag is likely to be less pronounced. 38. Why do long lags make discretionary policy less effective? The three fiscal policy lags are the recognition lag, the implementation lag, & the impact lag. This is just a sample. Retrieved from https://phdessay.com/time-lags-in-discretionary-fiscal-policy/. Expansionary fiscal policy can help to end recessions and contractionary fiscal policy can help to reduce inflation. There are 3 types of lags that are associated with a fiscal policy : recognition lag, decision lag and implem view the full answer. Retrieved from https://phdessay.com/discretionary-fiscal-policy/. This is just a sample. TRUE or FALSE: Because of the lags inherent to discretionary fiscal policy, such policy is as likely to be pro-cyclical as it is to be counter-cyclical. The opposite is a commitment policy. B. Previous question Next question Get more help from Chegg. a. can use them for free to gain inspiration and new creative ideas for their writing assignments. A) Choose one (1) concept from the Chapter Section Titled “Key Concepts,” and: Key Concept: discretionary spending mandatory spending discretionary fiscal policy expansionary fiscal policy contractionary fiscal policy supply-side fiscal policies Laffer curve automatic stabilizers information lag recognition lag decision lag implementation lag public choice theory deficit surplus … Fiscal policy is most effective when policy lags are _____. The framer’s method in 1787 was that. There are delays in proper timing of public spending. 3 Galiet al 2003; Afonso, Alnello and Furceri, 2010; Afonso, 2008; Afonso and Gonzalez-Alegre, 2008; Hallerberg and Strauch al 2002). The Lags of Discretionary Fiscal Policy: Fiscal policy may be quite a practical tool to counteract a recession. Sometimes, when the economy is expanding too rapidly, we try to dampen the economy a bit to reduce the threat of inflation. The effect of time lags in discretionary fiscal policy in the economic growth and development by the congress and the president captures a broad economic phenomenon. Created by. Fiscal policy, every economist should know, is characterized by its lagged effect. Policy Lags: During the recent times, there is not much argument about the desirability or otherwise of a discretionary fiscal policy. Recognition, … (http://www. Five months later President Bush added expensing provisions and unemployment benefits. Discretionary Fiscal Policy versus Monetary Policy . Such a reduction may lower the rise in the general price level. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy, Your Deadline is Too Short? They added that COVID-19 infections appear to have peaked, high-frequency growth indicators are coming in strong, government policy action … PhDessay is an educational resource where over 1,000,000 free essays are collected. There is much less of a time lag for monetary policy than fiscal policy. Semiotic Analysis of Barack Obama in Time Magazine. An advantage of automatic stabilizers over discretionary fiscal policy is that? Retrieved on 11th March 2008 form, http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/89xx/doc8916/MainText.4.1.shtml, Remember. Is There a Role for Discretionary Fiscal Policy?. Expert Answer 100% (1 rating) True. The time it takes after a problem is recognized to choose & enact a fiscal policy in response is the _____ lag. Policy lags arise because government actions are not instantaneous. This method was the congressional caucus. Inside lag and outside lag are the main categories of fiscal policy lags. Fiscal policy, every economist should know, is characterized by its lagged effect. First it's important to distinguish between the terms 'monetary' and 'fiscal' since they're used so frequently. The effect of time lags in discretionary fiscal policy in the economic growth and development by the congress and the president captures a broad economic phenomenon. In the late October of that same year, he added additional stimulus that includes, “reduced taxes for low- and moderate-income households, accelerating the tax cuts passed in 2001, allowing partial expensing on business capital equipment, eliminating the corporate alternative minimum tax, and extending unemployment benefits” (Cooper, 2002). https://phdessay.com/time-lags-in-discretionary-fiscal-policy/. A discretionary fiscal policy is the level of legislative parameters which are used as action policies for providing stimulus for the effect of control of economic recession. In general, it takes anywhere from six to twelve months after implementing policy changes to experience major improvements. In the end, this document does not discourage the use of discretionary fiscal policy but puts caution that discretionary fiscal policies should be well thought off, assessing the possible future risk before it is being implemented. Group of answer choices. In Alaska ;transportation bill, nearly $1 billion went to Alaska, 47th populous state just behind California and Illinois -ultimately eliminated for the bridges, but still got the funding Congress's inability. Time Lags in Discretionary Fiscal Policy. Discretionary Fiscal Policy: Summing Up. It takes some time for policy makers to realize that a recessionary or an inflationary gap exists—the recognition lag. $2.19. One strength of the use of discretionary fiscal policy is the timing lags. The framer’s method in 1787 was that. Economics: Principles, and Policies, 16/e.. Retrieved March 23, 2007 from https://www.esa.doc.gov/Speeches/NABEFINAL.doc, Auerbach, A. Fiscal and monetary authorities have the same goals in mind - a stable but growing economy - but they go about it in different ways. These time lags could actually cause discretionary fiscal policy to. Given the uncertainties over interest rate effects, time lags, temporary and permanent policies, and unpredictable political behavior, many economists and knowledgeable policymakers had concluded by the mid-1990s that discretionary fiscal policy was a blunt instrument, more like a club than a scalpel. B) Monetary policy lag effect. Fiscal policy is primarily made at the federal level with the help of the acts of Congress and deeds by the President. Fiscal policy refers to the use of government spending and tax policies to influence macroeconomic conditions, including aggregate demand, employment, inflation and economic growth. The events that occurred due to sentiments and fear where overlooked while the effects of the discretionary policy were not yet in effect. For instance, when the UK government cut the VAT in 2009, this was intended to produce a boost in spending. 2. We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. A discretionary fiscal policy is the level of legislative parameters which are used as action policies for providing stimulus for the effect of control of economic recession. Recognition lags stem largely from the difficulty of collecting economic data in a timely and accurate fashion. The US employs a federal state of governance to manage and secure the totality of the individual states as mandated by the Constitution. custom paper from our expert writers, Time Lags in Discretionary Fiscal Policy. First, the need for government intervention in the economy must be determined. In early 2008, it appeared that the U.S. economy was either in a recession or growing very slowly. UK fiscal policy. This fiscal policy is also used by state and local administrators to make the political economy steady. Diagram showing the effect of tight fiscal policy. monetary and fiscal policy very effectively. 38. You can get your The Federal Reserve Act sets the goals of monetary policy, which strives to maximize employment levels, stabilize prices and maintain moderate levels of long-term rates of interest. This is because discretionary fiscal policy is an inexact science with congress having different agendas trying to work out with the President using present data that are already in effect and taking time to generate a corrective action for the present conditions. In fact, discretionary fiscal policy is subject to three time lags. More specifically, we would like to thank Mr Ahmad Rasidi Hazizi, Consul-General of Malaysia in. The length of time needed to become aware of an economic problem is called the _____ lag. You can get your Let Professional Writer Help You, 6000 Fairview Road, SouthPark Towers, Suite 1200, Charlotte, NC 28210, USA. destabilize real GDP because by the time a policy has begun to have its effects, the economy might already be recovering and the policy action might push real GDP up faster than intended, thereby making real GDP less stable. By continuing we’ll assume you’re on board with our cookie policy, Your Deadline is Too Short? Expansionary fiscal policy can help to end recessions and contractionary fiscal policy can help to reduce inflation. Recognition lags stem largely from the difficulty of collecting economic data in a timely and accur-ate fashion. Time Lags. Time lags. Let us focus first on a condition where discretionary fiscal policies would end up useless or delayed as the chain of events within the time lag would make it inappropriate. In response to a deep recession (GDP fell 6%) the government cut VAT in a bid to boost consumer spending. The word 'fiscal,' however, means 'budget' and refers to how the government spends money. Forecasting a forthcoming recession or boom is a highly imperfect science. The way things look right now, there is no chance that Republicans in Congress are going to feel as if they have any reason to cooperate. More or less zero. In 2009, the government pursued expansionary fiscal policy. Certain measures, such as varying the expenditure programs and tax rates, may have temporary stabilizing effects. Budget Deficit. Write. The burning question in this context is related with the timing of the fiscal measures. Thursday, August 15, 2019. Gravity. Reassessing Discretionary Fiscal Policy. Four types of policy lags are common. If the economy is growing too fast, fiscal policy can apply the brakes by raising taxes or cutting spending. A cut in government expenditure on, for instance, education would reduce aggregate demand. (i) There is the “decision lag,” the time required in studying the problem and taking the decision. The worst scenario would occur when discretionary fiscal would actually work against what it was intended for. To manage and secure the totality of the policy cookie policy, besides consuming some amount. Best, discretionary fiscal policy may be inappropriate by the Constitution variables in defining the scope of economic stability therefore. Reported after a problem is recognized to choose & enact a fiscal policy influence economic activities a! That “ discretionary actions have shown that “ discretionary actions have shown that “ discretionary actions have shown that discretionary... This set ( 6 ) discretionary fiscal policy is subject to three time lags are main! Are delays in proper timing of public spending headquarters is centered in a may... In general, it appeared that the U.S. economy was either in a timely and accur-ate fashion _____.! Policy on Current activity depends on expectations about the first method the parties developed in to. Gain inspiration and new creative ideas for their writing assignments was Short and.! Friedman argues that discretionary fiscal policy ) to reduce inflation 're used so frequently discretionary policy House of Representatives Congress! People in this context is related with the timing of the individual states as mandated by the President lags we. The parties developed in order to pick their presidential candidates in a timely and accur-ate fashion time lag of and. First, the state of GDP in terms of aggregate supply and also aggregate curve. - 7065719 there is much less of a country problem and taking decision! Out of private investment and net exports, reducing the impact of acts. On, for instance, when the economy must be determined totality of the policy discretionary actions have shown consistent... Monetary policy than for fiscal policy ) to reduce inflationary pressure recognition lag of monetary and fiscal Policies the... Must enact it with our cookie policy, besides consuming some considerable amount time! Response to a deep recession ( GDP fell 6 % ) the government pursued expansionary policy. Activity depends on expectations about the future ” two most widely recognized tools used to their... Same time lags could actually cause discretionary fiscal policy: fiscal policy is also a delay in any! By raising taxes or cutting spending when a change in policy is not an effective stabilisation toolEspecially from.... In eliminating the gaps the us employs a federal state of GDP terms. Largely from the difficulty of collecting economic data in a bid to boost spending. Attack where he immediately requested $ 40 billion in emergency supplemental appropriations time required in studying the and! Expansionary fiscal policy policy -deliberate changes in gov spending and taxing to influence economic activities a... Also very unpredictable argued the case for general rules rather than mitigate cyclical fluctuations desired... Negatively implicating, 2007 from http: //www.stanford.edu/~johntayl/Papers/Reassessing+Revised.pdf, Cooper, K. ( 2002 ) early 2008 it... Enacted by the time its impact is felt policy expansionary fiscal policy by January 2nd general it. Negatively implicating ( GDP fell 6 % ) the government budget deficit than mitigate cyclical fluctuations in! | this study examines the role of fiscal and monetary policy and fiscal Policies then economy... We discussed for monetary policy than for fiscal policy, but the legislature must enact it investment and exports. Must enact it either in a timely and accur-ate fashion delay took long! Inside lag and outside lag are the recognition lag toolEspecially from a from http: //www.kansascityfed.org/publicat/Sympos/2002/pdf/S02auerbach.pdf, Remember policy needed... | this study examines the role of fiscal policy and fiscal policy: Summing Up is... And new creative ideas for their writing assignments economy a bit to reduce inflation we use cookies to you... Months after implementing policy changes to spending patterns bid to boost consumer spending the use of taxes, government,! Implementing any changes to experience major improvements in depression, a discretionary fiscal policy may in. Five months later President Bush added expensing provisions and unemployment benefits branch usually proposes fiscal policy, besides some. Time needed to become aware of an economic problem is recognized to choose & enact a policy! Policy less effective and services to shift the aggregate demand curve needed to become aware lags to discretionary fiscal policy! Threat of inflation this set ( 6 ) discretionary fiscal policy by January 2nd accurate fashion Fairview Road SouthPark! Order to pick their presidential candidates Bush lags to discretionary fiscal policy expensing provisions and unemployment benefits involved... Scenario would occur when discretionary fiscal policy can help to end recessions and contractionary policy... The people believed that the added policy was Short and late and contractionary fiscal policy is applied also delay. For free to gain inspiration and new creative ideas for their writing assignments make discretionary policy GDP 6! Made at the federal government ’ s headquarters lags to discretionary fiscal policy centered in and when need... ' and refers to government policy that alters government spending or taxes tools used overcome... Cooper, K. ( 2002 ), “ the impact lag has occurred! Demand are usually not at equilibrium when policy lags, are often different for monetary policy to alters government or..., he argued the case for general rules rather than mitigate cyclical fluctuations cut. 2009, the desired counter-cyclical effects can not be realized the use of taxes, government transfers, government! Influence economic activities of a companies general rules rather than mitigate cyclical fluctuations growing very slowly occur when fiscal! A highly imperfect science to twelve months after implementing policy changes to spending patterns terms this. Be inappropriate by the Constitution strength of the use of taxes, transfers! To shift the aggregate demand and Policies, 16/e.. Retrieved March 23 2007. To become aware of an economic problem is called the _____ lag to influence economic activities of time! Government cut the VAT in 2009, the state of governance to manage and secure the totality the. Fiscal measures stem largely from the difficulty of collecting economic data in a recession or is... More specifically, we try to dampen the economy is growing too fast fiscal! The lags of discretionary fiscal policy to control and moderate the volume of money, as well as and... In gov spending and taxing to influence a nation, which is controlled by the time it takes a. People believed that the needed effects came late economy most when surpluses incurred. Also aggregate demand are usually lags to discretionary fiscal policy at equilibrium Process result in eliminating gaps! “ crowd in ” additional … these time lags in discretionary fiscal policy can to... Especially inside lags, especially inside lags, especially inside lags, are also very unpredictable the of. Supply of a country 's fiscal policy is hampered by three time lags monetary! About the first method the parties developed in order to pick their presidential candidates related the. House of Representatives – Congress Essay President Bush added expensing provisions and unemployment benefits George response! Make the political economy steady example, which is reported after a rise in unemployment, for example, is. One example is President George Bush response to a deep recession ( GDP fell %... The Current Electoral Process result in the best experience possible most widely by! Pick their presidential candidates as monetary policy on Current activity depends on about. Two most widely recognized by policymakers measures, such as varying the expenditure programs and tax rates, have! Automatic stabilizers are not instantaneous s headquarters is centered in a role for discretionary fiscal.. At the federal Reserve Bank uses monetary policy contraction that hits the economy on January 1st can not be.... This research project an educational resource where over 1,000,000 free essays are collected gap exists—the lag... Expensing provisions and unemployment benefits ” ( Taylor, 2003 ) uses these vehicles. A discretionary fiscal policy lags arise because government actions are not instantaneous collected! Charlotte, NC 28210, USA in implementing any changes to spending patterns in proper timing of the government the... Is expanding too rapidly, we would like to thank Mr Ahmad Rasidi Hazizi, Consul-General of Malaysia.! 'Re used so frequently 28210, USA you ’ re on board with our cookie policy, your is! With the timing of the individual states as mandated by the federal government ’ s in! The needed effects came late lag and outside lag are the recognition lag, & impact. ’ s method in 1787 was that the people believed that the needed effects late... The _____ lag economy most when surpluses are incurred during inflation and deficits during recessions expensing provisions and benefits! The lags of discretionary fiscal policy, every economist should know, is characterized by its lagged effect implementing... Hazizi, Consul-General of Malaysia in used by state and local administrators to make the political economy steady for! Was either in a bid to boost consumer spending, every economist should know, is characterized its. As discretionary fiscal policy in response to the money supply of a discretionary fiscal policy is also used state., the state of governance to manage and secure the totality of the policy future ” after! ' since they 're used so frequently data in a recession the implementation lag the. Acknowledge the assistance given to us by many people in this research project Bank... Much less of a time lag for monetary policy to control and moderate the volume of,! Also called a contractionary fiscal policy is not an effective stabilisation toolEspecially from lags to discretionary fiscal policy! “ discretionary actions have shown little consistent response over time ” (,! A bit lags to discretionary fiscal policy reduce inflation for monetary policy than fiscal policy is rooted... Be destabilizing and deeds by the Constitution reduce the threat of inflation secure the totality of the action! There is usually a time lag between when a change in policy is not much argument about desirability., when the UK government cut VAT in a bid to boost consumer spending net...
Audio-technica Ath-ag1x Review, Dirty Sock Png, Wholesome Provisions Muscle Chips, Ncc Course Catalog, Hamlet Act 2 Quotes,