Because this status quo was not liked by Britain – that seems to be rather obvious. The Treaty ended the state of war between Germany and the Allied Powers.It was signed on 28 June 1919 in Versailles, exactly five years after the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand, which had directly led to the war. Buchanan argues that both world wars were unnecessary and that the British Empire's decision to fight in them was disastrous for the world. But what if Britain had been defeated at Dunkirk? Maybe Lord Halifax became Prime Minister instead of Churchill (who could have died beforehand). This paper examines major peace initiatives during World War I. As he had stated repeatedly in his book as well as in his speeches he wanted space for the Germans in the East. Germany's possible defeat of Britain in 1940 is by some distance the national treasure trove of might-have-beens. Well that allows great speculation, if Great Britain were to make a loose peace which allowed them to go to war with Germany after they have been to war with the USSR for a large amount of time, Then perhaps Great Britain and the USA could take … Maybe Dunkirk was a massacre and Churchill was sacked in favor of Halifax. 100% Upvoted. There's also nothing to stop the British from reintering the war or at least supporting the Soviets in this scenario that I can see. share. In July, following the Fall of France, when Britain stood almost alone against Germany, Hitler offered peace. save hide report. This is highly hypothetical of course, but lets for the sake of the argument assume that Britain had accepted the peace offer by Rudolf Hess and had broken a peace with Germany in June 1941, what would that have meant for the German campaign against the Soviet Union? Some politicians inside and outside the government were willing to consider the offer but Churchill would not. The question should also be asked Who rejected whose offer? Britain was … He had no claims in the West. But America DID, eventually, join the Great War. Chamberlain died on 9 November the same year. He was an open admirer of Britain and its Empire. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. The Treaty of Versailles (French: Traité de Versailles) was the most important of the peace treaties that brought World War I to an end. best. Facing the worst crisis in the history of the British Empire, Halifax believes that in order to preserve that empire, Britain must seek a … But one can say that a victorious Germany, imposing peace … Hitler refused to consider them. Marshal Pétain, 84 years old and the great hero of World War I, believed it was his duty to save France from total destruction and accept an armistice with Germany. Churchill, Hitler and the Unnecessary War: How Britain Lost Its Empire and the West Lost the World, is a book by Patrick J. Buchanan, published in May 2008. Let's imagine that Britain made peace with Nazi Germany in June 1940 after France fell. If Churchill had made peace, this would have allowed Britain to defend Malaya and Singapore with sufficient forces and save the Far Eastern Empire. Hitler was desperate for peace in the West. This thread is archived. There was no chance of America joining the the second world war in … The Treaty ended the state of war between Germany and the Allied Powers.It was signed on 28 June 1919 in Versailles, exactly five years after the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand, which had directly led to the war. It was Britain's Grand Fleet that made possible the blockade that starved Germany of raw materials and especially food, which starved 400,000 Germans … As history goes, it's counterfactual, but far from far-fetched. What if Britain Had Made Peace With Hitler? On 26 September Hitler made a speech at the Sportpalast in Berlin in which he claimed that the Sudetenland was "the last territorial demand I have to make in Europe," [18] and gave Czechoslovakia a deadline of 28 September at 2:00pm to cede the territory to Germany or face war. The Poles made a series of offers to Hitler before and on 1st September 1939. ... such as land, money, colonies etc, and would have also made them accept blame for ww1. The main protagonists were Prime Minister Winston Churchill and Foreign Secretary Viscount Halifax.The dispute escalated to crisis point and threatened the continuity of the Churchill government. Let's re-iterate some points: 1) I read from the title of the scenario that this was Britain alone concluding a deal with Germany but if it is an Anglo-French proposal, that puts a different slant on things. Hitler rejected them. Britain made a series of offers to Germany before 3rd September 1939. In May 1940, during the Second World War, the British war cabinet was split on the question of whether to make terms with Nazi Germany or to continue hostilities. Thanks for the comments, englander1, not sure I agree with any of them but fair enough. What were German plans for Britain if they had successfully occupied the UK in World War 2? I think it might have been, and here’s why: Had Great Britain decided to make peace with Nazi Germany, then the UK would have to give up Egypt to Italy and accept the take over of France and the establishment on Vichy France. Without a … The Treaty of Versailles (French: Traité de Versailles) was the most important of the peace treaties that brought World War I to an end. ... do you mean if Britain signs a peace treaty or if Germany successfully invaded and occupied the UK?